Showing posts with label musing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label musing. Show all posts

Friday, November 23, 2012

Musings On the Nature of Gamebryo, #1656E

For literal years now (since mid-2009), I've tried to tell people that Gamebryo's -- specifically Fallout 3's (and later Fallout NV's; which is hands-down the greatest expansion pack ever) -- reliability is inversely proportional to the number of followers you have in tow.

Over the past six or so weeks since Skyrim got boring and my attention flitted back into FNV territory, this has been demonstrated yet again.

In my first "hardcore-hardcore" game -- no companions, no freebie equipment; all by my lonesome, using only armor and weapons that I could find, steal, buy, or loot -- my FNV set a personal record for longest continuous up time without a crash: about four hours and ten minutes -- and at the end of that, it didn't crash; I exited normally because... y'know... it had been four fucking hours and I really needed to get up and move around before I got a goddamned blood clot or something.

Shortly thereafter, Mystery-chan used her infernal powers to cajole/guilt me into letting her come along so we could adventure together.

This brought up-time back into more familiar -- but still outstanding by my standards -- territory of about three to three and a half hours play before a crash; depending on what we were doing.

Since then, I've started other games and characters to test other things without messing up the hardcore game; or what-have-you.

With a second companion in tow, average up time falls back to my old normal three hours -- sometimes as light as two and a half if I'm running a mod I know damned well I shouldn't because of its shoddy coding (we won't go into which mod or why -- it isn't that kind of blog).

With all three of my beloved girls in the party, we average about two forty-five; and it usually ends up being a crash on loading a new cell.

Two forty-five to three hours, I should note, is a comfortable zone for me. It's not great reliability, no; but it's about the area where I start needing to get up off my dead ass and move around.

Last night, I got in a couple play sessions with all three dogs in tow. While they're not following me; they are none the less companions. They follow their respective mistresses, have companionscripts, and all that. The only real difference is the target of the following packages. The companionscripts for the dogs are comparatively simple -- 154 lines each (less than a quarter the size of the girls' scripts) -- but nonetheless, six "companions" on screen at any given time had an immediate and easily noticeable effect.

Day before yesterday, when I set the game up and did some early-game crap around Goodsprings, I played for an hour and thirty minutes before the crash.

Last night/this morning, according to the date stamps on the save files, I played for precisely one hour and forty minutes before it crashed.

Even while running, though, it was causing problems. Framerates were noticeably lower; and the engine's script bottleneck was in full and blatantly obvious effect -- it actually stopped Mystery-chan and Maeva's hardcore code from functioning correctly.

This, I should note here, is one of the reasons I haven't jumped in and released a companion for you monkeys to break that features the full hardcore companion mode. Certain mods that take over the NPC's AI can cause the code to break; and if your game's cache is overloaded or nearing full, the code can stop functioning correctly at random -- for instance, last night the code would run correctly if they had gecko steaks in their inventory to eat; but wouldn't run if they had yum-yum deviled eggs. Why? Who the hell knows. Gnostic mysticism is easier to make sense of than this game. I've tried scripting out around it several times; but when the hardcore code fails it also breaks their following behavior -- which then has to be manually reset... it's kind of a mess and I haven't been able to make it suitably reliable yet unless kept to one companion -- and we all remember how well that recommendation went back in RR.

Anyway.

I've noticed time and again that the two biggest culprits in system load (and therefore crashing) are loading new cells -- especially in the open wasteland -- and at the start of combat.

"But Nos!" I can hear you hunt-pecking out on your keyboard; "New cells don't load in the wasteland! Cells only load when you see a loading screen!"

You're wrong. The wasteland is actually broken up into cells; a number of which adjacent to the cell you're in are displayed in the distance (controlled by the Ugridstoload setting in your .ini). When you come within appropriate range, the next cell in the distance begins to load; LOD at first, but as you move to within range as defined by your graphics settings, full objects will "pop in". The moment of pop-in is where I find most of my crashes occur by a wide margin.

A close second is when the combat AI fires up. As I've said in the past I don't know what in the unholy Hell the AI is doing when it does that... but the system load spikes and sits there for several seconds. I don't know whether it's just switching on combat styles; or if it's plotting specific behavior... hell, it could be plotting to overthrow humanity and using FNV as a simulation to test battleplans for all I know.

It seems once again like I've hit the wall; and FNV just doesn't have the ability to handle what I want it to be.

I'd hoped Skyrim with its "new and totally original" (excuse the noise I'm making; I'm totally not snickering...) engine would be a step in the right direction. Sadly Papyrus is utter shit; and their improved script queuing overloads faster and easier than it did in Gamebryo.

So yeah. Maybe it's just the four hours of sleep talking, but I'm pretty discouraged tonight. I may try a reduced party with one companion and one pooch... but beyond that I think the dogs will need to spend most of their time lounging around the estate like I originally intended.

Sunday, May 27, 2012

Random Companion Musing #1344C

No, this still isn't the post detailing all the neat new stuffs I've learned to do with companions during the latest modding binge. Deal with it.

While playing yesterday, I had cause to pick up Cass and Veronica (via the Unlimited Companions mod available on the Nexus) to test an ancillary feature of another mod I was playing with (a non-game breaking one, as far as I can tell).

I already had Veronica, but needed more points in speech or barter to successfully get Cass, and so dropped into Vault 11 (which we happened to be near to) to get in some kills and get another level. I had Veronica kitted out with Brotherhood T-51b recovered from Repconn HQ, and one of the GRA unique energy weapons; I forget now whether it was the Gatling laser or the plasma caster.

I had left Natasha at home to cut down on system load spikes and general traffic jams, but still had Mystery-chan and Maeva in party to keep us an even fire team.

When we got into the Vault, I was floored by the difference in performance between Veronica and my two redheads.

As soon as the red marks appeared on the HUD, my girls went hunting. They generally go full-on search & destroy whenever the AI registers an enemy trying to find and/or attack me, and this time was no different. They saddled up and took off in a team, clearing every enemy they could detect.

Leaving them to their fun (and knowing full well I'd not manage to get a single XP out of the deal even if I did tag along) I headed on for the reactor room.

Along the way I was amused to hear several shots from a riot gun, followed by "You like that?!" Never a dull day with that demon around...

Veronica, apparently not being the type to run off on a killing spree, stayed with me. Moving through, I had the odd mantis to deal with myself. I had put away my M14 and was using a marksman carbine loaded with .223 -- since I'm not going to waste my good ammo on bugs and rats -- and after capping a couple, I was amazed to turn around and find Veronica... hiding. Crouched behind a corner, didn't even try to engage the enemy.

Conversely, a couple days ago we happened to be cleaning out another area with rats; and one got the jump on me. Natasha -- the least aggressive of my girls by a wide margin -- still put eight rounds into the rat, even though I turned and capped it from the hip with my BFR. I guess she wanted to be sure it was dead.

Later, when heading into the diner area, I was shooting mantises out around the furniture... to, y'know, avoid setting off the boobytraps and all. What should I hear from behind me? "For the Brotherhood!"

Oh, Gods, she's not going to...

...and about that time, a power-armored brunette blasts past me into the diner, setting off the explosives.

Fortunately, I'm quick on the uptake and ran like hell for cover as soon as I realized what she was doing. The explosion blew her clear across the room (would have killed her, if not for the little edit I made to her essential flag -- case in point as to why it's important, "realism" or no) and even as far away as I got, crippled both my legs and took me below 20% health. Well, there goes a doctor's bag and hydra I didn't want to spend...

So, let's tally score:

*Refuses to engage in normal combat, when I am being attacked.

*Charges in and sets off traps when I'm trying to fight from a distance and not in immediate danger.

*Defaults to nigh-useless melee combat style; can not engage in proper ranged combat without mods.

...and people wonder why I create my own companions...

Shortly after that, the sadistic duo caught up with us, just in time to brush the debris off of me. I like to imagine there would have been some vehement recriminations in Veronica's general direction if they were able.

On the rest of the way through the Vault, I found that sure enough -- they had killed everything they could find. All that remained standing was a few bugs that had been behind locked doors; and of course the robots in the basement.

You don't want to know what the M14-equipped redheads did to those poor combat droids... In that fight, Veronica even managed to get off one or two shots; while the rest of us were going for broke.

Did learn a new method for screwing over that trap, too. Laid a pair of pulse mines on one of the walls where it opened up to let the robots kill me; and as soon as the wall opened I shot the mine. Its explosion triggered the second mine, and the two pulse waves knocked out a couple of the combat sentries or whatever the big 'bots are called on that side; just leaving the turrets to clean up. While I was doing that, my girls handled the protectrons on the other side, and the whole fight lasted all of about seven seconds; with no injuries on our side.

Once acquiring Cass' services, I found she was little better. For all her talk, she's not very aggressive; and won't range far looking for an enemy. I suppose that could be considered a good thing, since it means she and Veronica stay near the player... I guess I'm just too used to my companions; who very much have a "lead, follow, or get out of my way" thing going on when a fight breaks out.

I'm still tempted to try rewriting their behavior into an actual squad dynamic -- that is, staying with the player even when combat breaks out -- but previous attempts haven't gone well. Before I tried an actual formation: each person having a specific spot in the stack, and staying where they're supposed to... but it broke the game. While they'd fall into formation correctly, for some reason it precluded their actually entering combat. Never did figure out why. That was in FO3, though; it may be less bad in FNV (though I doubt it).

Failing that, I'm also thinking of a behavior setting -- similar to NCCS' follow distance, except it'll swap them to a different follow package that has 'continue during combat' checked, rather than a different distance. 'Continue during combat' for those of you who don't do AI packages, when used on a follow package has the NPC stay close to the player even when a fight breaks out. They try to stay at the specified distance from the follow-ee, and rather than running off to attack, will only engage enemies as they come into range on their own. Given the relative lack of medical care in the wasteland, and just how nasty most of the beasties are, I'd think sticking together would be the better option anyway.

...Damn it, now I want to script that up; but I still haven't finished unfucking the game, itself yet...

Saturday, November 26, 2011

The Other Hardcore Mode

Reading around the Lovers Lab forum tonight... because I'm, well, severely bored. Normally just keep track of Oblivion stuffs, but I happened to pop into the FO3/NV section. Looking over a thread on a mod called "Sexout" which is a general perverse addon for NV; apparently based on some half-finished Japanese mod for FO3. The thread was about "what do you want to see in the mod?"

Glancing down the lists; usual fare -- raping, drugs, slavery, animal sex; all the stuff you normally see on wish lists for these sorts of mods.

Then I saw it.

"Support for NCCS companions somehow"

So many conflicting thoughts. I mean, there's the "ew" of course -- I'm not against dirty mods in any way, but that whole drugging and raping and slavery thing... it's not me -- but there's also "hey, I guess some people do use the mod!" followed by "I bet I could run out a compatibility plugin..." to "...do I want an official compatibility plugin for that sort of thing...?"

I wonder: am I wasting my time on the wrong kind of "hardcore mode" for NCCS? Popularity for the mod does seem to lie down the wet-spot-stained road...

Monday, August 1, 2011

Interesting

Since playing FNV again, I've ended up thinking again about the need for a proper complex for housing myself and my companions.

To that end, I loaded up the NVGECK again this morning; in order to see if the new versions of engine and construction set would allow me to load the 'Lucky38 World' to copy and replicate the rooms with views.

It crashed, again. To be fair, I was expecting this, and so barely looked away from my DVD when the program shit itself and returned to the desktop.

Thinking on why the NVGECK would load other cells fine -- even inordinately large worldspaces like the wasteland -- but not anything to do with the Lucky38's replicated wasteland, the thought occurred to me that it might be a graphical issue; something in the worldspace that my video card or DX environ didn't care for.

I switched off all non-essential objects in the viewer: sound markers, collision planes, occlusion planes, trees, grass -- everything but lights and normal markers.

Tried loading the worldspace again, and this time was rewarded with it loading normally. I return to my DVD.

About ten minutes later, I glance back to the GECK, and see that the items-to-be-loaded counts haven't dropped by even one. I look closer, and see that Windows' "working" cursor has stopped moving. Great; the numbers aren't going down because it locked the system up. Another fine Bethsoft job, I see.

Ctrl+Alt+Del wouldn't bring up the windows manager either -- it was a legitimate hard lock.

Based on the symptoms, and the fact that Herculine can load the Lucky38 world for editing where I can't, I'm now inclined to believe the issue isn't so much that the GECK itself is crashing on the one world and no others -- I think it's a resource issue. There's something in that worldspace that's such a resource whore that it's more than the entire wasteland's system drain; it's just flat more than my little PC here can handle rendering.

What is it? Your guess is as good as mine. The wasteland copy is supposed to be empty; and only stretch as far as you can see from the windows. That said, as anyone who's modded a Gamebryo title before can tell you, "supposed to be" rarely coincides with "is".

So, this pretty much puts the kibosh on my tower in FNV. I'm back to working with standard interiors; and that being the case I'm far more likely to go underground than above -- maybe create some Bond-villain-esque underwater complex in Lake Mead or some such.

All that said, I have something I want to ask you guys. Bearing in mind that "underwater" does not have to equal Lake Mead (I can just as easily claim it's an underground aquifer as I did with the Vault 1 Remodel) where would you want to see player housing?

As I was playing through this new game, the thought occurred to me that if I did place the complex at the lake, I wouldn't be able to access it until at least level six; often closer to ten, for the simple fact that Obsidian railroaded us so hard that you can't go straight to the lake from Goodsprings. Short of installing some lame-o teleporting device or transport service, there's no way to go direct without it being tantamount to suicide. You pretty much have to take the long way south and around past Nipton.

While I realize that Goodsprings -- much like Springvale in FO3 -- is far and away overcrowded with house mods because it's the starting location, I'm nonetheless wondering if somewhere nearer there wouldn't be better for earlier access.

At the same time, though, easy(er) access to New Vegas and its surrounding areas would also be nice, since there's fuckall for merchants and amenities in the Goodsprings area.

With so much free space north of the Strip, it would be pretty easy to pull a Resident Evil, and claim that the NosCo Evil Corporate Headquarters are secreted beneath some farmhouse and fields.

Of course, there is also the lake. It would be equally easy to say the scavenger's platform is chained out there in the middle as a cover to keep anyone from noticing an observation bubble from the underground complex.

Decisions, decisions.

Although as I'm playing a more survival-oriented character in this game (and hardcore mode), I keep thinking it would be nice to have a hydroponic garden in the complex, as well as a water purifier of some sort.

Friday, February 4, 2011

NCCS - Curious

Had a curious thing happen last night while I was playing dead.

Seems a companion-maker decided to, rather than simply use NCCS as a master, fold the entire mod into his companion plugin.

Now, this isn't going to be a "stole my stuff, con sarnit!" rant. I listed NCCS as freely reusable on the Nexus, so long as attribution is given. He kept it to the Nexus, and gave credit, so I'm not pissed off or anything.

What I am is wondering.

See, the whole concept behind NCCS, much like CM and RR before it, is that I as the system author, cannot know the RefIDs of the companions made with the system. So, all scripting has to be done in a roundabout fashion to account for this fact.

NCCS was folded into EVE-900 though, to drive one single companion. Now, maybe I've been writing my own systems too long, but it seems to me that writing a new framework from scratch to drive a single companion would be far less trouble in the long run, than trying to keep a create-your-own system updated inside your plugin.

Conversely, wouldn't it have been easier to just flag NCCS as a master? I mean, the master archive is less than a hundred kilobytes. Is it really that big a deal to download?

I realize NCCS looks super cool and spiffy and all to most of you guys who use it, but copying the entire mod to run one standalone companion is like using a 12 gauge to kill a field mouse - sure, you can do it... but it's hardly the optimal tool for the job.

But, hell, what do I know?

I nonetheless wish our intrepid modder much success with his creepy robot companion, regardless of what ends up under the hood.

Sunday, January 30, 2011

On "the Wheel"

In the course of downloading an up-to-date copy of the ACM Wheel Addon for NCCS, I decided to peruse the comments on the file. I saw one that caught my attention, and really sheds a lot of light on the prime difference between me, and most companion users (and makers, as well).

"I don't get why so many people are against the wheel, besides it just being new and different. It reminds me of the Sneak/Activate popup menu CM Partners has for Oblivion.

Instead of: Activate. Let's talk about your tactics. Let's talk about how close you follow me. Follow me at a distance. Let's talk about something else. Let's talk about your tactics. Switch to melee weapons. Let's talk about something else. Goodbye. ...

... you have: Activate. Click Range. Click Melee.

I really like having this stuff be quicker to access.
"

Personally, I had never looked at the wheel that way. Why? I don't micro-manage.

When I create a companion, I create the companion I want. If I want a sniper; that's how I class them. If I want a support gunner, or a melee scrapper I set them up from the get-go to be what I want.

So, for me, being able to switch follow distance and combat style and combat range is all completely useless. It's worse than completely useless: it's in my way.

My companions? I give them a weapon, and make sure they stay stocked on ammo and stims. Beyond that, they can fight however their little silicon heart desires.

In real life, I'm one of those people that as long as you get the job done, I don't care how you prefer to do it. If it works for you? Great! I'm not going to stand there glaring over your shoulder and railing on you to do it my way.

Similarly, in games I set up the basic behavior to control the role I'd like the companion to fill; some specific actions in the case of special events that may arise... and outside of that I let the AI do its own thing, in its own way.

I've never understood the people who need to issue a command to companions every two minutes.

I fear this will forever hold my companion systems back. Since I don't understand the need; I have a hell of a time implementing features to that end.

I kind of wish I could include the AI that lives in my computer with the mods themselves. Companions so damned good that they don't need to be given orders. But, of course someone would just start bitching that they're not nine year old Asian girls, or that they don't like engaging in combat with a knife when there are guns available. Plus, the AI-spirits would be pissed at me for exposing them to so much stupidity, so y'know... probably not the best idea after all.

Monday, January 24, 2011

More Oblivion

I mentioned last week how I had the strong urge to copy Colourwheel's revamped Khajiit race and make up some catgirl companions.

Well, last night I got to sleep from 2200 to 0200; so I had some time to kill, and guess what I did to kill it?

Say hello to:



Ako.




Eiko.




Keiko.




And Yuuko.

The names, of course, being a blatant ripoff of the four named members of the catgirl maid squad in UFO Ultramaiden Valkyrie - because they were the only catgirls I could think of off the top of my head at 0400, and as always I suck with names. I was tempted to call them Maids A, B, C, and D... but I figured that would go even further over everyone's heads.

They are, in order: a Battlemage, an Archer, an Assassin, and a Warrior.

Permission issues from Miss Colourwheel aside... I'm not sure this plugin is uploadable, as it stands.

As previously mentioned, I use and like Nequam's eyes. Trouble is, Elaborate Eyes doesn't work with Colourwheel's Overhaul. I modified my copy of her esp to make it work - because I can make it work, I see no reason to have to pick one or the other - and likewise the copied race is set up to use these eyes as well. So, unless you're CS-savvy, the plugin wouldn't actually be playable. So if I were going to share, I think I'd have to axe that part, and reset it to use default eye meshes.

I'd say I could just list a disclaimer in the readme... but I've learned first-hand over the last twenty months how many of you actually read those (hint: more people endorse than take the time to read the fucking manual before bitching in my general direction that it doesn't work).

As I just finished the Purification quest for the Brotherhood, I'm also thinking of throwing together a plugin to repopulate the sanctuary. I know; more generic murderers will move in later; but they look terrible to begin with - and make for shitty companions, to boot.

Still need to take a look at Colourwheel's revamped vampire race (oh, the wit!) while I'm thinking about it. Haven't run into one in-game yet, but if they turned out as well as the others, I may finally be able to make some vampire companions that don't look horrific.

Wednesday, December 29, 2010

Radar.

You people have it, I swear.

A guy tries to take a couple days off, to wade through all the crap involved in getting Lovers running in an Oblivion install (a mod that I am so not linking here, by the way) to see if it's actually as good as people are always going on about. Complex, pain in the ass in general; lots of readmes in Japanese, translated into a form of English that bears no semblance to the real thing. Rather like the old Babelfish translations, now that I think of it...

Anyway. While I was playing with silly adult mods, malcontents have started in again.

A new modder going by badreaper001 has kindly released a new NCCS package with about a half dozen companions. Hampered at the moment by a player who decried that the mod needs the wheel. When pointed to ttomwv's wheel addon for NCCS, he now complains that the wheel conflicts with some other companion mod.

Fucking duh.

Tarrant predicted this about a week after NV went gold; and I've been telling it to people for weeks. No one listens. The problem is the "wheel" buttons don't do anything directly. They're like shortcuts to dialog commands. Trouble is, these shortcuts are hard-coded to be read from only one dialog topic; and the game only allows one override to any given topic. Any further changes simply override the previous override. This means that you get ONE companion mod that will work with the wheel.

I can't fix it. Don't ask. There is no way to code out around it that I'm aware of.

If you people would pick a freaking mod and be done with it, it wouldn't be an issue; but everyone has to have eighteen different companion mods running at any given time.

This is why I won't add the wheel to NCCS by default. I said it before, I'll say it again: conflicts. When and if I can make it reliably selectable, then maybe - but for now I'm not willing to compromise compatibility for the legions of indecisive players who don't read the manual but love posting derisive comments.

The one and only fix I'm aware of to the situation would be to create a sort of merged patch. Problem is, the auto-patch creators that are so favored by the community won't do it. They can't combine multiple edits into one, as far as I'm aware - they only allow you to select which of the combined plugins' edits you want to make dominant. The fix would be to combine all plugins (or at least make one plugin that references all companion master files you use), and manually write in the dialog commands for each companion (or system) into a single edit of the pertinent quest.

Doable? Absolutely; but not on my end. There are simply too many companion mods out there; too many permutations and combinations and options. I could write a hundred merge patches and not cover the possibilities.

And considering that I don't even use NCCS, my odds of spending a week or six writing compatibility plugins for NCCS and every other companion I can find are somewhere akin to the odds of Mars slamming into the Earth next week.

Malcontent #2 is from my RR Companions Pack for FO3. He thinks my eye textures look bad. To which I reply: fuck you and the horse you rode in on. You don't like them? Upload better, or sit down and shut up. I do not take shit about the quality of my mods off of people with eight posts, no kudos, and no uploaded files.

Malcontent #3 actually brought me to a dead stop. As far as I could discern from the PM, the issues revolves around the fact that he is for some reason using Notepad++ to edit a companions plugin for RR, and this is resulting in the script not staying set on the companion. I got an email with an rtf file attached (rich text? Really? What, did I stumble into the wayback machine and end up in 1999?) that when opened was full of encoded game data, master file lists, and resource paths for what looked like a custom race. I offered what advice I could without invoking profanity... but I haven't read the reply PM yet. I did receive another email though that claims to have a copy of the esp file attached... which I also haven't read yet. I'll get around to it; I just need ample time to zen-ize my mind to prepare.

I was telling Herculine the other day that I'm thinking about giving up modding as a hobby. I'm considering taking up something more relaxing... like defusing old Soviet mines in Africa. Anyone know how to say "I need QuikClot!" in Kirundi...?

Monday, December 20, 2010

On Criticism

A commenter on the last post brought up an interesting issue - whether I'd want to receive comments, if they weren't positive.

This, I thought, deserved its own post; rather than being relegated to the comments basement.

The theory behind this was that many artists can't handle criticism. Okay, I'm a writer, and modder and general monkeyer-with of all things vidja gaem; but I don't know that I've ever been described as artist.

Several other appellations have been thrown on me over the years... just not that one.

So, this gets me thinking. I bitch a lot about what I term 'the complainers'. Do I really not take criticism well? Am I being dishonest with myself - saying that I want comments, when I really only want vapid, sycophantic praise?

...

Nope. Had me worried there for a second.

Let me explain how commenting and criticism in general works.

I don't get paid for this. None of us do - such things are specifically against the EULA we all agreed to when installing our games and our toolsets. Making money off of our mods is, in fact, a hefty violation of international copyright law.

So, when you criticize a mod, you are in point of fact saying: "Hey, I don't think your work is good enough to be given away for free!"

No matter how you word it, this is a blow to the modder's personal ego. It doesn't matter how long you've been 'sharing' work; how hard you did or didn't work on it; or how much you tell yourself you don't really care.

But, criticism can be good, as long as it's constructive. Once you get past the sting, you can start to look at the comment itself, and see whether their concerns can actually improve your work.

Case in point: I bitch heavily and often about people who "comment" only with 'your mod doesn't work!', 'your mod needs to be X before I'll consider endorsing it!' and of course my personal favorite, the thumbs-down with no comment whatsoever.

On the other hand, when Herculine or ttomwv or Fry or the good Sergeant or any of a dozen other people come to me with an issue - with something that they think could be done better, I listen. I sit down and consider it before replying. Is it possible? Would it really be an improvement? If yes, I try it. If no, I try to explain why it isn't viable.

Why do I listen to one group, but dismiss the other? It's all in how you approach it.

Constructive criticism. Don't just tell a modder that something sucks. Take the time, think about it, and give them an alternate idea; how could it be good/better by your standards?

There's also the secondary matter that some stuff just ain't ever happening in a game mod. The sad fact is that most players have never and will never mod. They have no idea what is and is not possible in a game engine; or how long something will take to implement if it is possible.

Because of this lack of practical knowledge, they come up with unreasonable expectations. Some people expect a mod to rival the base game itself in content and quality. Granted, the quality bit is easier to equal in some games than others.

Then, there's the matter of motivation and time constraints on practicality.

I'll cite you and example here. Many moons ago, ttomwv wrote plugins for the RR Companions Vault that expanded the sorter in the armory. One handled the items for FOOK2, and one for 20th Century Weapons. These were written early on in the respective mods' lives; when item counts were still comparatively small. By the middle of this year, each of the two mods boasted more than five hundred new items.

To make the sorters work, each item needs a minimum of three lines of code; sometimes four or five. Bare minimum, that would be fifteen hundred lines of code for each mod. Twenty-five hundred if you weren't lucky. Then there are containers to store it all, since the point of a sorter is to separate your loot automatically. 20thCW would need a dozen or more containers; FOOK2 probably many more. Then there's testing. Every single line of code has to be proofread. Every sorting option tested - which means collecting or console-spawning some of nearly every item in the game. Figure on about a 10% bug rate where a typo or mis-pasted line will cause an option to not work right, and you have to re-do fifty of those items at least once.

So, was it possible? Yeah, sure. Was I going to do it? Oh hell no. We're talking about a solid week of six to eight hour days doing nothing but coding and testing; and for what? Something I wouldn't even use - an "option" that I think is a waste of time to begin with?

So, the TL;DR version: criticism is fine; but think before you hit post. If you can't tell me how it could be better, just telling me it's bad probably won't get you anything more than dismissed.

Wednesday, December 1, 2010

FONV Hair Problems

Really not in the mood to write html this morning (I truly, truly hate working with that garbage), so stuffed the creation guide onto the back burner for another day or two.

Rather, I've been working on some new NCCS features. New 'go home' features that will allow sending your companion to the Lucky 38 suite or Novac motel room (provided you've acquired their use). Worked out a new (for me, anyway) method of sending the companion home that totally does away with the unreliable travel packages I used in RR.

Added Pip-Boy lights.

Worked out details on some other features that will be worked on in the future but not disclosed at the moment for a few reasons.

Anyway. In the course of testing, I got 'round to be frustrated by Maeva's hair problem.

Wondering whether it was my altered mesh, or the game in general, I popped out Ling's in the GECK and got to looking. All hairs display perfectly, there.

Extracted that mesh over the top of the one I use. Check, and again: bald spot.

This makes me wonder.

When FONV first hit, I remember reading that it had some issues with resources not contained in a bsa file.

Since the only difference between Earache42's hair and mine is that he uses a bsa and I don't, I'm wondering if this problem isn't wider reaching than originally thought.

I'll confess I'm not keen on having to build bsa files. They're a straight-up pain in the ass for modders to work with; since resources can't be referenced in the pack; they have to be extracted, paths set up, assigned to their objects in the GECK, and then packed. Anytime you need to alter a mesh or change a path, the bsa has to be extracted and remade.

Still... I'm thinking it might behoove me to throw together a small one just for my special companions, to test and see if that unfucks the hairs...

Monday, November 29, 2010

More NV Strangeness

Annoyed as I am with the 'community' in general this morning, I decided to play with my personal companions some. I added Natasha to the plugin - fortunately, her hair works perfectly in NV.

Got plugin set up and quest written and et cetera et cetera.

Happened to be testing; and she got stuck in some rocks - clipping into them and unable to get out. Normally, I'd open the console and toggle clipping on her, but I decide what the hell, I'll try out the plugin's recall function. Probably a waste of time, since it never worked in testing on my pre-made NCCS companions.

This time? Worked without a hitch. Exact same code, save for the references. Why did it work this time and not before?

I have no idea. None whatsoever.

This only reinforces the theory I've had though, that at certain times, the engine hangs. Scripts hit a certain line and won't process anymore. In the case of my NCCS pip-boy plugins, it was the line that governed reset code.

Apparently it doesn't hang in my special companions plugin.

I swear, Levi's and Crowley's magickal theories made more sense than this damned game.

On another hand, I think I'm going to have to try talking Maeva into a new hair style. I'm not seeing "adjusted" versions of Ren's work popping up on the Nexus; and Gods know I don't have the Blender skill to do it myself.

Don't want to cut her to short hair, though. I'm thinking maybe one of those Growlf hairs. With the braids. Maybe that twin-braid one, with the tails hanging down on her chest. Go for that Alpine look.

Saturday, November 27, 2010

Possible Revelation?

Got my girls upgraded, back into the game, and running some new code that takes my previous "go find the player" starting package a step further.

Decided to give them some combat trials. We headed into Vault 11.

Performance was excellent; they swept and cleared the place in a manner that would've made any Delta Force operator proud.

It got interesting at the end, though. I had moved into the sacrificial chamber, and from the focus on the projector and the general shape of the room; I could smell what was coming, and had moved well out of the line of fire.

Needless to say, the firefight was fairly epic; and involved my expending several hundred caps worth of 40mm grenades.

Anyway. What caught my attention - and necessitated a post - was that about halfway through, I got the 'sound bug' for want of a better term; where firing, reloading, and other "item" sounds just stop playing.

At the end of the fight, both my companions were stuck.

Alas, ED-E had been ravaged like a narcoleptic cheerleader on prom night, so I couldn't see whether it had frozen as well.

Rather than use the wait key, I just left them standing there while I explored the new room. As I did, sounds played - albeit slowly and in a disjointed fashion, rather than the every saved up sound at once that it usually does.

When the sounds had finished catching up... the AI unfroze, and the girls put away their weapons and joined me.

I'd never seen this correlation before, but on deeper consideration, it's all coming together.

The AI freezing, the sounds stopping, the scripts that freeze at random.

Something in the game engine is hanging at random. Once it hangs, any new input it ignored. You can't activate affected NPCs, scripts don't fire, holstering of weapons doesn't work.

And, I'd wager, if it stays fucked long enough, that's when you get the crash. A memory request that goes unheeded or something.

Trouble is, because I lack the software to peep into the executable and see what in the holy hell is going on with the engine, this is all base supposition. Even if it wasn't, hacking the engine itself is way above my pay grade. So, even if I am right... what good does it do us?





Either way, it's good to have them back. Those lesser companions were beginning to cramp my style.

Tuesday, November 23, 2010

FONV - Done Right

I bitch a lot around here about the devs; what I think they could have done better, or shouldn't have done at all - but I'd like to take a few minutes here to mention some things I think they did right.

Firstly, the Presidential Suite in the Lucky 38. This is the first official 'player house' I've seen in TESIV, FO3, or FONV that I actually liked and may well use to the exclusion of a self-made home. It's upgradable without being pointless (see the "themes" from FO3 for what I mean by waste of my fucking time and caps), has plenty of storage, and can sleep four companions in addition to me. Six, if I let them take my bed, as well. My one complaint about the suite is that it lacks a reloading bench or campfire-equivalent; so that you can't do all your crafting at home.

Second, The Strip from a distance. Wow. I watched the sun rise over the Strip from outside the Followers Safe House, and damn; what a view. There's about a half hour in game time where you can see the sun cresting the horizon, while the Strip lights are still on.

Third, Fisto. Congrats, Devs, you successfully made me inadvertently cringe.

Fourth, Crafting. I like the new system. I don't personally use it, but it's nice to have the ability to make Stimpaks myself. Reloading is especially nice; I'm impressed that they went as far as primers and powder type. Kudos, there. Would be nicer if you had to spring for a die set as well as the "recipe", but it's still a massive improvement over other systems where you magically make all ammo out of "powder" and scrap metal.

Fifth, Gun Runners. I like the kiosk design, and how it makes it all but impossible for the player to steal weapons and ammo.

Sixth, Sex. No more beating around the bush (oh, the wit!) here; for once they actually flatly acknowledge that it goes on, and you get to flirt with and even possibly engage in said acts with NPCs. Granted, you don't get to see anything... but it's still better than pretending we're all eight and live in a giant Disney movie where the height of intimacy is holding hands.

Seventh, Gambling. I'm not much of a gambler here in the real world. I know that eventually, the house always wins. Otherwise, they wouldn't stay in business. That said, I developed a bit of a taste for dice poker while playing The Witcher, and it's nice to see another game that lets you wager a bit for something different than running packages and killing raiders. Unfortunately, as in real life, I completely suck at New Vegas Roulette. Not horrid at blackjack, but could certainly live without Caravan; that convoluted mess.

There are also some parts I don't agree with. Not going to delve into bugs, or lapses in setup in some area; this is just the ways things are 'supposed to work'.

Mainly, it's those asinine level requirements on items showing up in a merchant's inventory. Really? We still have to deal with this shit? Look, walk into a store sometime, here in the real world. Do they ask you how old you are? If you want to wear an expensive suit, do they ask how long you've been wearing pants? Of course not. Retailers care about whether you can pay the number on the price tag. Really, it's time to do the same in games. Remove the requirements, let the player buy whatever they can swing the price of. I mean, Combat Armor goes for upwards of four grand in NV, level one players aren't going to be able to afford that anyway.

There's also the matter of the NCR. You devs think Californians are the greatest race to ever walk the face of the Earth. We get it. Now lay off. I'm seriously considering siding with Caesar just because I'm sick of dealing with those blowhards and their OMG SO GREAT backstory. Have you read any of the in-game stuff surrounding them? It reads like a seventeen year old's fanfic dedicated to their favorite branch of the military. Not only are the NCR Rangers the greatest ever, but there's a level still greater! The Super Saiyan... I mean ELITE NCR RANGERS! With their high gloss black armor and expertise in not only every form of combat ever, but also as scouts. PH34R!

...I was so hoping taking control of ARCHIMEDES II would let me turn the death ray on NCR positions around the wastes... but noooooo, it's a one-shot deal that only kills the ones in the courtyard.

We won't even get into how badly the voice actors are mutilating their pronunciations. I haven't heard Latin that bad since I got bored enough to watch Harry Potter on Cinemax once at three AM.

Okay, someone just came through and talked to me. My train of thought is even more derailed than it was when I started the tirade, so I'll shut up now.

Monday, November 8, 2010

Even More Oblivion Weirdness, Cont.

Fired up the game to cruise through Apachii's Goddess and Heroes stores; blow some cash I had left over after purchasing Benirus Manor.

I pop open my inventory, to double-check some stuff I had acquired in the cleaning out of Benirus...

...and what do I see? The chainmail cuirass and composite greaves that disappeared into the aether last game.

At this point, I'm beginning to wonder if the field where they grow the pomegranates for my tea doesn't also have some peyote stashed in it here and there; and some of the stuff ended up making it into this lot.

There's no way this isn't a hallucination.

Although... I usually hallucinate things more interesting than Oblivion bugs. Normally it's giant malicious spiders or elder gods of Darkness or occasionally the daughter I don't have.

Sunday, November 7, 2010

More Oblivion Observations

Still working with the CS.

My initial attempt at a standalone was a fairly resounding failure. I won't go into heavy detail about what all I was doing, but suffice to say that despite engine similarities, Oblivion and Fallout 3 are very different games where NPC behavior and interactions are concerned.

Doing my best to adapt and overcome, and am making headway.

I'm continually amused, however, by the constant contradictions I run across.

As I observed before, my primary issue has been in accessing the companion's inventory via dialog.

Reading around forums and dissecting other people's work had led me to believe that it was fairly involved - that the container need be moved to the cell you currently occupy, and some other considerations made.

Deciding to look elsewhere from CM, I opened up the esp from Montana's Sexy Companion II - which is hands-down one of if not the best companion ever made for Oblivion.

Montana's solution for the inventory was a simple call on the dialog: "pgchestcasual.activate player, 1"

The rest is handled within the OnActivate block of the chest's object script. This runs counter to what I had been able to divine from various readings. Ostensibly, after all, a container won't activate if it isn't in the same cell as the player. No activate == OnActivate block never fires.

That said, in near four years of use, Astrianna's inventory has never once failed to open for me.

It also turns out that amongst its many other companion flaws, Oblivion doesn't transport party members automatically when you fast travel. Different companions and systems handle this different ways, but all of them have had to add in extra functions to keep the companion(s) in question with you.

I'll confess I had always wondered a bit, but after doing it in reverse, I now understand why so many Oblivion modders had a hell of a time transitioning to FO3.

You NV modders seem to have lucked out.

Wishlist

As I sit here, working in the Oblivion CS, I can't help but think of a feature that would be really nice.

No, not bug fixes.

(I know those are out of the question.)

What would be great is a check-box that filters whatever list you're looking through, so that it shows only entries flagged as modified by your plugin.

Would make things so very much simpler.

Saturday, November 6, 2010

Oblivion Observations

After a particularly inspiring chat with my muse/co-scripter/reason for not being dead earlier this evening, I decided to push my Oblivion companion work a bit further. I'd thus far been tinkering with a new companion system of my own devising, but I've now shoved that plugin aside and started in on a new one centering around my favorite companion, [CENSORED].

I'm implementing not only my testing stuffs for possible future use in a CM modification... but also some goodies that I want just for me and may well never see the light of upload.

While setting up some basic dialog, I saw just how truly fucked Oblivion is, as far as companion makers are concerned. I had known FO3 was a step up; but not this big a step.

In FO3, when you wish to access a companion (or any other NPC, for that matter)'s inventory, you simply set them as a teammate and use an openteammatecontainer call.

I was setting up the inventory share dialog in the new plugin, and couldn't recall Oblivion's function for said calling. I got to reading the CS wiki. It turns out I couldn't remember the function to call because there isn't one.

Oblivion has no provision whatsoever for directly accessing an NPC's inventory.

I'll say that again: None.

But Nos, you say, CM does it! All those companion mods do it. There must be a way.

Oh, there is, but it redefines the term 'needlessly convoluted'.

In Oblivion, to access companion inventory, one must have created a container for said NPC. Container must be moved to the same cell as the player, all NPC inventory transferred to container. Container then force-activates the player. Inventory share what-have-you commences. Container's inventory is then dumped back on to NPC, and an item added, equipped, and removed to force an equipping update. Container is then moved back to its home cell, to await the next call.

Now, this means one of two things, as far as I can see.

1) Bethsoft devs are the most oblivious people to ever create a game, and never looked farther than the end of their own noses.

2) Bethsoft devs legitimately thought that players would never need to access an NPC's inventory for any reason.

I had always thought they considered companion NPCs to be an afterthought... but damn.

I knew this was going to be a pain, but I was hoping it wouldn't be this much of one...

Thursday, October 14, 2010

Introspection and Cyclical Time

Was PMing back and forth with my favorite little fairy again tonight; and again on the subject of Oblivion. In the course of it, I ended up linking (and re-reading) some old blog posts of mine from early this year.

It was interesting to see that back in February I was bitching about much the same things as I am these days: stupid people who can't RTFM, and a general feeling of getting no fun from modding anymore. What one might call burn out.

Interesting to see how history repeats.

Yeah, I realize I burn out about twice a year - but you guys can't imagine the number of stupid people I have to deal with since getting the RR Companions Vault dropped wholesale into my lap.

The last couple times I've gotten past it by dropping off the face of the Earth for a week or two, and working just on mods that I enjoy; and not any fan requests of bug fixes or what-have-you.

Trouble is, I've been trying that for nearly a month now. Granted, I haven't gone so far as to stop responding to PMs and file entry comments; but things have changed. These days there are a handful of you guys that I don't want to ignore - and would consider myself more than a bit rude for doing so.

It just isn't working. I'll confess, I enjoyed working on the penthouse level of the Tower last week, but as soon as I got into the more interesting features, the frustration started. After some thought, I think the issue is that after almost two years, I know the engine and GECK so well that most of my new ideas push the envelope; I've got the engine doing things that it was never meant to do, and at this point every time I try to take it a step further, I hit the wall.

Similarly, all of my later companion ideas take the NPCs further; deeper options and interactivity, more lifelike behavior. Some of it works in my testing, but even that which does I'm leery to release. It works on my system with my mod environment and load order. Experience has taught me a lot of it won't work once exposed to the staggering myriad of overhaul mods that fuck with everything under the sun and then some. Other ideas aren't viable simply because they'd lock the player into using a particular mod or other; and I don't like doing that.

It's more than a bit of a dilemma. On the one hand, my - for lack of a better term - artistic integrity (yes, I do have some, thank you very much) tells me not to put out something less than my best effort. On the other, as a long time player of other people's mods, I know perfectly well that some mod is better than none, and doubtless at least some would get enjoyment from what I can beat the GECK into allowing.

I have to confess that at this point, I miss being a new modder. Yeah, I can write a companion script freehand now; set up a combat style without incremental testing; even alter models to add things like a glow effect and create the requisite glowmap to make it work... but I really miss the thrill of accomplishment - the idea (fallacy that it was) that anything was possible if I could just figure out the scripting tricks...

Nowadays I know the limits, the pitfalls, the bugs and boons; and for it, my digital world seems smaller and less bright.

Aw, hell, don't mind me. I'm apparently having one of those fatalistic nights.